Anyway the motors and switches work fine and you can open the windows a certain amount before they seem to de-rail, the offside almost instantly and the drivers gets reasonably low before dropping of the rail.
What is strange (Ianaudia4 had acknowledged cheers mate) is that the rubber insert on the front guide rail doesn't go all the way down to the base of the door on the drivers door (see arrows, blue has no rubber)
The other side does (see light coloured strip of rubber)

I've read that this front rail sometimes is worth replacing on other VW's , Would the rail from a manual door work with electric windows or is this the problem? also is there anything strange about the install? I'm actually wondering if they have ever worked properly, just had another look and there is all sorts of non standard bolts and screws used? Tempted to fit manuals.
